
MTG Proxy Artwork: How to Choose the Right Card Print for Your Deck
MTG proxy artwork is the one part of proxying that costs you nothing to get exactly right. Scryfall lists 146 different printings of Sol Ring, drawn by 64 different artists, and every single one of them prints as a proxy for the same US$0.80. Pick the Mark Tedin 1993 original, the MSCHF 2026 art, or the inverted-frame Secret Lair version — the rules on the card never change, and neither does the price. The reason it matters is that the same card costs wildly different amounts in paper. Swords to Plowshares ranges from US$0.10 to US$1,701.98 across its 102 printings; Dark Ritual runs from US$0.44 to US$299.99. Artwork is the one variable in proxying where you get the premium for nothing. This guide covers what the frame treatments mean, how to find the exact print you want, and how to bulk-search a whole decklist without clicking through 100 card art pickers.
What This Article Covers
- Why the artwork choice is free in proxies and expensive in paper — the real numbers
- The five frame treatments that explain most of a card’s price spread
- How to find a specific printing by set, artist, and collector number
- Bulk art selection for a 100-card Commander deck in a few searches
- Where to stop — when art choice stops mattering
The Price Gap: Same Card, Wildly Different Prices
Start with the fact that makes this worth an article. Take thirteen cards that appear in nearly every Commander deck and price every printing of each one on Scryfall. The cheapest printing of all thirteen, bought together, costs US$191.39. The same thirteen cards, chosen in their most expensive alt-art and premium frames, cost US$2,873.08 — 15 times more.
That table is the whole argument for printing your own cards. The most expensive Sol Ring printing on Scryfall — the Tarkir: Dragonstorm version by Randy Gallegos — lists at US$2,223.22 today. Printed as a proxy it costs US$0.80. The rules text is byte-for-byte identical. Only the illustration changed.
Read the same table the other way and you get the real insight: artwork is the cheapest premium in Magic. There is no way to get a US$1,701.98 Swords to Plowshares art into a paper deck for less than US$1,701.98. As a proxy, the premium is exactly zero.

The Five Frame Treatments That Drive the Price
The price spread above is not random. Scryfall tracks the visual treatment of a card through two fields: `frame` (the edition of the card frame — 1993, 1997, 2003, 2015, future) and `frame_effects` (the artwork treatment layered on top). The official Scryfall frame documentation lists every effect. Five of them account for nearly all of the value you are chasing.
Showcase. A custom frame treatment, introduced with Commander Masters and now used for premium art in almost every set. Example: Craterhoof Behemoth in Tarkir: Dragonstorm (TDM #414) by Magali Villeneuve, a showcase-plus-inverted frame.
Inverted. Predominantly inverted text, introduced with the Secret Lair drops in 2022. This is the single most valuable frame effect in the game right now — it is what makes Swords to Plowshares (SLD #713, Justin Hernandez & Alexis Hernandez) a four-figure card.
Extended art. An extended-art frame, where the illustration bleeds past the normal card border. Sol Ring has exactly one: Commander Masters Edition #700 by Mike Bierek.
Etched. An etched-foil treatment reserved for the most premium products in a set. Craterhoof Behemoth has one, in Commander Masters Edition #556.
Enchantment. An enchantment-specific frame, which you will meet on Rhystic Study and a handful of other enchantments.
The pattern is consistent: the more the frame deviates from the standard template, the higher the price. In paper, that is what you are paying for. As a proxy, the frame is simply part of the scan.

How to Find the Exact Print You Want
You do not need to guess. Every printing of every card is indexed by set code and collector number, and that is the number you use to request a specific one.
Step one — search by card name. Searching “Sol Ring” on Scryfall returns all 146 printings grouped by set. The URL format is the same everywhere: `scryfall.com/card/{set}/{collector_number}` — for example `scryfall.com/card/sld/713` for the inverted Swords to Plowshares.
Step two — filter by artist. If you want the Josh Mandagli art rather than the Mark Tedin art, the artist name is on every printing. Sol Ring alone has been drawn by 64 different people, from Mark Tedin and Jesper Ejsing to MSCHF.
Step three — check the frame effects. On a printing’s page, the frame treatment is listed under the card details. `showcase`, `inverted`, `extendedart` and `etched` are the four worth chasing.
Step four — note the collector number and request it. On MakeProxyCard you can search a card by name and pick the exact printing you want from the results, or upload your own image. Every card in a proxy order is the same card — the frame, the set symbol and the collector number are all reproduced exactly as the original.
The practical shortcut for most decks: use the same printing for every copy of a card. If your deck runs four Sol Rings, all four should be the same art. A proxy deck where one Sol Ring is the 1993 original and another is the 2025 borderless version reads as a mistake at the table, and it is the kind of thing other players notice immediately.
Bulk Art Selection for a Whole Decklist
The reason most players never choose their own art is the workload. A 100-card Commander deck means 100 decisions, and clicking through 100 individual card pickers is exactly the kind of friction that makes you accept whatever art comes up by default.
You do not have to. Search by card name, not by collector number, and the picker returns every printing of that card in one place — the MakeProxyCard card search shows all 140 available Sol Ring printings side by side, with set names and full-resolution art, so you can scan a decade of artwork for one card in a few seconds. The card search also accepts multiple names at once, so a 100-card list is a handful of batch searches rather than 100 lookups.
A faster rule for most decks. Pick one aesthetic and apply it. If your deck is built from modern Commander staples, using the newest non-promo printing of each card gives you a consistent look. If you want the vintage feel, pick the earliest printing of each card — the 1993 and 1994 sets are the classic frames and they are the cheapest in paper anyway, which means they are also the ones you are most likely to have in your collection already.
Where art choice stops mattering. For a card you run at US$0.31 in every printing — Brainstorm, Dark Ritual, Swords to Plowshares in its 30th Anniversary version — the artwork genuinely does not matter. There is no display value in a card you can buy for pocket change. Spend your attention on the three or four cards in your deck that are actually worth looking at.

The Bottom Line: What Art Costs You
Thirteen cards in their best frames cost US$2,873.08 in paper. The same thirteen cards, printed with exactly that artwork, cost US$10.40 as proxies at the US$0.80 per-card rate — a US$2,862.68 difference for identical cards.
That gap is the entire reason to print your own cards, and it is why choosing the artwork matters. Every proxy service that only gives you the default printing is quietly charging you for the premium frame you did not get and the artwork you could have had.
MakeProxyCard prints every card at up to 1200 DPI on 350gsm blue-core cardstock in exact MTG dimensions, from the specific printing you pick — or from your own uploaded artwork for altered-art decks, themed cubes and house designs. Whether you want the 1993 original, the inverted Secret Lair, or something nobody else has, the price is the same US$0.80 per card.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
All print counts, artist counts and prices in this article were pulled live from the Scryfall API on 18 November 2026. Artwork is © Wizards of the Coast; card images are © Scryfall.
- Scryfall — Sol Ring, all 146 printings across 64 artists
- Scryfall API — Frames and frame_effects documentation
- Scryfall — Swords to Plowshares, all printings
- Scryfall — card prices (USD)
- MakeProxyCard — official pricing tiers and live card search
- MakeProxyCard — browse custom artwork
- Magic Judges — MTR 3.4 Proxy Cards
- EDHREC — deckbuilding tool and card popularity data
Related Reading
Start with the prices guide if you want the raw tier arithmetic, or the quality guide if you are comparing what you receive against what you ordered.
- MTG Proxy Prices 2026 — the full quantity tier table behind the US$0.80 per-card rate used here
- How to Spot Quality MTG Proxies — cardstock weight, finish and finish-quality benchmarks
- How MTG Proxies Are Printed — what happens to your file between the cart and the sleeve
- The Complete MTG Proxy Guide 2026 — the pillar hub covering legality, costs, quality, formats, storage and etiquette
