
Sisay cEDH: The Five-Colour Tutor Engine That Wins Games
Sisay cEDH is a five-colour tutor-combo deck built around Sisay, Weatherlight Captain and her {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} activation, which searches your library for a legendary permanent with a mana value below her power and puts it onto the battlefield. The core idea is simple: flood the table with legendary permanents, pump Sisay until she is enormous, then tutor out whatever wins the game. According to cEDH metagame data from MTGMeta, Sisay holds 5.3% of the competitive field across 292 recorded lists, ranks fourth in the format, and a full paper build costs roughly US$10,950.
This guide walks through the 100-card singleton list, the 10 cards that make the tutor chain work, how the combo line actually resolves, the commander variations competitive players run, and what a proxy-first version looks like for players who want the full experience without the five-figure price tag.
| 📋 Table of Contents | |
|---|---|
| 1. | Deck Identity |
| 2. | The 100-Card List |
| 3. | The 10 Key Cards That Make Sisay Work |
| 4. | How Sisay Wins Games |
| 5. | Common Commanders |
| 6. | Matchups: What to Expect in cEDH |
| 7. | How to Get Started |
| 10. | Related Reading |
Deck Identity
The 100-Card List
The reference list is the 100-card singleton that finished 4th at the Basic Mountain Games cEDH League on November 4, 2026. It breaks down as 27 creatures, 2 artifact creatures, 2 enchantment creatures, 18 instants, 11 artifacts, 7 enchantments, 3 sorceries, 2 planeswalkers and 28 lands — 100 cards exactly. Every card is Commander-legal and within Sisay’s five-colour identity.
The list plays:
Costing all 100 cards live against current market pricing puts the paper version at US$10,949.93. The mana base is where the money is: 28 lands come to US$7,826.08, or 71.5% of the entire list, while the 72 non-land cards come to US$3,123.85.
The single most expensive card is Gaea’s Cradle at US$1,649.66 — one card, 15.1% of the deck on its own. Mox Diamond is US$1,119.70, Underground Sea US$1,099.49 and Volcanic Island US$1,007.98. The ten most expensive card types are 73.1% of the list. Every one of them is a land or a mana rock, which is the single most important fact about the cost of this deck.
Source: MTGMeta — Sisay, Weatherlight Captain cEDH archetype · full card text, mana costs and prices for all 100 cards pulled from the Scryfall API, with each card valued at its default print, or the most recent non-promo market print where the default print carries no price.
- Creatures (27): Badgermole Cub · Birds of Paradise · Bloom Tender · Deadpool, Trading Card · Deathrite Shaman · Delighted Halfling · Derevi, Empyrial Tactician · Elvish Spirit Guide · Emiel the Blessed · Faeburrow Elder · Gilded Drake · Ignoble Hierarch · Ioreth of the Healing House · Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy · Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff · Noble Hierarch · Orcish Bowmasters · Ragavan, Nimble Pilferer · Ruby, Daring Tracker · Samut, Hazoret’s Champion · Selvala, Heart of the Wilds · Shang-Chi, Master of Kung Fu · Sisay, Weatherlight Captain · Spider-Woman, Stunning Savior · Tam, Mindful First-Year · Tataru Taru · The Cabbage Merchant
- Artifact and enchantment creatures (4): Colossal Skyturtle · Enduring Vitality · Esper Sentinel · Marvin, Murderous Mimic
- Instants (18): Abrupt Decay · An Offer You Can’t Refuse · Chord of Calling · Deadly Rollick · Deflecting Swat · Dismember · Fierce Guardianship · Flusterstorm · Force of Will · Into the Flood Maw · Legolas’s Quick Reflexes · Mental Misstep · Mindbreak Trap · Silence · Swan Song · Swords to Plowshares · Vampiric Tutor · Worldly Tutor
- Artifacts (11): Agatha’s Soul Cauldron · Arcane Signet · Chrome Mox · Loki’s Scepter · Lotus Petal · Mana Vault · Mox Amber · Mox Diamond · Mox Opal · Relic of Legends · Sol Ring
- Enchantments (7): Cryptolith Rite · Deafening Silence · Gleaming Splendor · Mystic Remora · Rhystic Study · Smothering Tithe · Touch the Spirit Realm
- Sorceries (3): Demonic Tutor · Finale of Devastation · Green Sun’s Zenith
- Planeswalkers (2): Teferi, Time Raveler · Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler
- Lands (28): Ancient Tomb · Arid Mesa · Bayou · Boseiju, Who Endures · City of Brass · Command Tower · Exotic Orchard · Flooded Strand · Gaea’s Cradle · Gemstone Caverns · Mana Confluence · Misty Rainforest · Mount Doom · Otawara, Soaring City · Plateau · Polluted Delta · Savannah · Scalding Tarn · Scrubland · Taiga · Tarnished Citadel · Tropical Island · Tundra · Underground Sea · Verdant Catacombs · Volcanic Island · Windswept Heath · Wooded Foothills
The 10 Key Cards That Make Sisay Work
Sisay’s ability asks for two things: legendary permanents to raise her power, and mana to pay {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} repeatedly. Every card in the 99 exists to serve one of those two needs.
Sisay, Weatherlight Captain — The Commander
Sisay is a three-mana 2/2 Human Soldier with two abilities that define the entire format interaction. First: “Sisay gets +1/+1 for each color among other legendary permanents you control.” Second: “{W}{U}{B}{R}{G}: Search your library for a legendary permanent card with mana value less than Sisay’s power, put that card onto the battlefield, then shuffle.”
That second ability is the whole deck. It is not limited to once per turn, it costs the same five colours every time, and it puts the permanent onto the battlefield rather than casting it — so it bypasses every “cast only” restriction and sidesteps counterspells, since nothing goes on the stack to be answered. Note that it does not bypass summoning sickness (rule 302.6): a creature put onto the battlefield this way still cannot attack or tap for a {T} ability until the following turn. Each additional colour among your other legendaries adds +1 power, which raises the mana-value ceiling she can tutor for. At 7 power she can fetch any legendary permanent with a mana value of 6 or less, which is nearly the whole card pool.
Source: Scryfall — Modern Horizons 1 #29, illustrated by Anna Steinbauer.
Agatha’s Soul Cauldron — The Mana Engine
Agatha’s Soul Cauldron is a two-mana legendary artifact with three separate functions, and it is the reason Sisay lists run fast mana at all. First: “You may spend mana as though it were mana of any color to activate abilities of creatures you control.” That single clause means five green mana from Gaea’s Cradle can pay a {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} Sisay activation. Second: “Creatures you control with +1/+1 counters on them have all activated abilities of all creature cards exiled with Agatha’s Soul Cauldron.” Third: “{T}: Exile target card from a graveyard. When a creature card is exiled this way, put a +1/+1 counter on target creature you control.”
Source: Scryfall — Wilds of Eldraine #242, illustrated by Jason A. Engle.
Enduring Vitality — The Two-Tap Engine
Enduring Vitality is a three-mana 3/3 Enchantment Creature — Elk Glimmer with vigilance, and one ability that reshapes the whole mana base: “Creatures you control have ‘{T}: Add one mana of any color.'” It also has a safety net — “When Enduring Vitality dies, if it was a creature, return it to the battlefield under its owner’s control. It’s an enchantment.” That death clause means a single copy is enough. The moment it is on the battlefield, every creature you control is a one-mana rock of any colour, which is what turns a two-mana Bloom Tender into a five-mana activation of Sisay, or a one-mana Enduring Vitality into a five-mana activation on its own.
At US$14.65 it is also the cheapest permanent in the deck that changes how mana works, and it is the reason the list can afford to run a 28-land manabase with only two rocks in the conventional sense.
Source: Scryfall — Duskmourn #176, illustrated by Valera Lutfullina.
Emiel the Blessed — The Reanimation Engine
Emiel the Blessed is a four-mana 4/4 Unicorn with two halves. Its activated ability, “{3}: Exile another target creature you control, then return it to the battlefield under its owner’s control,” is the flicker engine that makes the whole deck loop. Its triggered ability, “Whenever another creature you control enters, you may pay {G/W}. If you do, put a +1/+1 counter on it. If it’s a Unicorn, put two +1/+1 counters on it instead,” turns every reanimation into extra power on your board.
Emiel is what turns a single mana dork into an infinite sequence. Because the creature returns to the battlefield, it triggers its own enters-the-battlefield abilities all over again — and because the deck runs so many creatures with enters-the-battlefield value, that is where the deck’s tempo comes from.
Source: Scryfall — Double Masters 2 #10, illustrated by Antonio José Manzanedo.
Derevi, Empyrial Tactician — The Untap Engine
Derevi is a three-mana 2/3 Bird Wizard with flying and two abilities that make her the second half of the infinite-mana loop: “When Derevi enters and whenever a creature you control deals combat damage to a player, you may tap or untap target permanent,” plus her commander ability “{1}{G}{W}{U}: Put Derevi onto the battlefield from the command zone.”
Combined with Emiel, the sequence is: use Emiel’s {3} to exile and return Derevi, which triggers her enters-the-battlefield ability to untap your mana source. Tap the mana source again, and you have generated more mana than you spent. Repeat indefinitely. That is how a five-colour deck with no ritual in it produces infinite mana.
Source: Scryfall — Commander 2017 #176, illustrated by Michael Komarck.
Orcish Bowmasters — The Damage Outlet
Infinite mana means nothing until you have a way to convert it into a win, and this deck runs two. Orcish Bowmasters is a two-mana flash 1/1 with “When this creature enters and whenever an opponent draws a card except the first one they draw in each of their draw steps, this creature deals 1 damage to any target. Then amass Orcs 1.” Because it has flash, you can cast it and then flicker it with Emiel to get a second damage trigger, and a third, and a fourth.
Mount Doom is the other one, and it is the reason the deck plays twenty-eight lands. It is a legendary land with three separate modes: “{T}, Pay 1 life: Add {B} or {R}”, “{1}{B}{R}, {T}: Mount Doom deals 1 damage to each opponent”, and “{5}{B}{R}, {T}, Sacrifice Mount Doom and a legendary artifact: Choose up to two creatures, then destroy the rest.” Tap it, deal one to every opponent, untap it with Derevi or Ioreth, and repeat until the table is dead.
Source: Scryfall — Lost Caverns of Ixalan #258, illustrated by Jonas De Ro.




How Sisay Wins Games
Sisay wins in three stages, and the deck is deliberately built so that each stage has a fallback if the opponent stops it.
Stage 1 — Deploy the engine (turns 1-3)
Get mana online and cast Sisay. The fastest openings use a mana dork — Noble Hierarch, Birds of Paradise or Delighted Halfling — to cast her on turn two, then add a second colour source. From there the deck’s whole purpose is to get more legendary permanents onto the battlefield, because each colour among them makes Sisay bigger and raises her tutoring ceiling. Selvala, Heart of the Wilds and Emiel the Blessed are the two most common ways to do that.
Stage 2 — Build the tutor chain (turns 3-5)
Once Sisay is online and you have five colours available, you start activating her. Each activation costs {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} and fetches a legendary permanent with a mana value under her power. Agatha’s Soul Cauldron is what makes this affordable, because it lets you treat any colour of mana as any other colour. The sequence the community converges on is to tutor out Emiel the Blessed first, then Derevi, then use the pair to produce infinite mana.
Stage 3 — Convert to a win (turns 4-7)
With infinite mana, you filter it through Sisay’s activation to fetch the finisher you need. The three most common wins are all on the board already: Orcish Bowmasters for repeated point damage, Mount Doom for one damage to every opponent at once, and Gilded Drake — a two-mana 3/3 flyer that exchanges control of itself for any creature an opponent controls the moment it enters. Because Sisay can tutor out any legendary permanent with a mana value below her power, the fourth and fifth options are the planeswalkers the list runs — Teferi, Time Raveler to lock down the turn and recur a permanent, and Tyvar, Jubilant Brawler to mill three cards and put a creature back from your graveyard.
If the combo is disrupted, the deck still wins. Sisay is a 2/2 that becomes an 11/11 or larger in a stalled game, and with Rhystic Study, Mystic Remora and Tataru Taru generating card advantage every turn, the fallback is simply out-drawing the table.
Common Commanders
Sisay is a five-colour legendary creature, and the competitive community runs her in a small number of recognisable ways.
Sisay, Weatherlight Captain (Standard — Five Colour)
The canonical build, and by far the most common. Five colours means every colour-specific staple is available: Mox Diamond and Chrome Mox for rocks, the full suite of dual lands, black tutors like Demonic Tutor and Vampiric Tutor, and the white interaction suite. The cost of the fifth colour is that the land base has to work hard to fix all five, which is why the mana base is the most expensive part of the deck. Every published Sisay list MTGMeta tracks runs Command Tower, City of Brass and either Gemstone Caverns or Exotic Orchard for exactly this reason.
Captain Sisay (Selesnya — Two Colours)
Sisay is not the only legendary tutor in the archetype’s orbit. Captain Sisay, a two-mana Selesnya legendary from the same Universes Beyond cycle, has “{T}: Search your library for a legendary card, reveal that card, put it into your hand, then shuffle” — a legendary tutor that fetches a legendary card rather than a legendary permanent. It plays a different game: a two-colour white-green deck with a much smaller card pool, a lighter mana base, and a longer game plan that leans on the legendary bodies it draws rather than on assembling a five-colour chain. EDHREC’s “similar commanders” list for Sisay also surfaces Jodah, the Unifier, Esika, God of the Tree, Kenrith, the Returned King, Kethis, the Hidden Hand and Shanid, Sleepers’ Scourge — all legendary-heavy shells that can field a comparable plan.
Why the Community Runs One Commander
The important thing to understand about Sisay in cEDH is that she is the archetype. MTGMeta’s play-rate data across 292 published competitive lists puts Sisay herself in 100% of them. She has no partner ability, so she cannot be paired at the command zone — the “two commanders” build that defines Blue Farm and Rograkh simply does not exist for this deck. Everything that makes the archetype work comes from her {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} activation and from the legendary permanents that raise her power, and those legendary permanents are the deck’s real content.
That is also why the shell is unusually expensive relative to its power. The Commander singleton rule (903.5b) forces a different English name for every card, so a five-colour deck cannot run the four-copy staples it wants — but it also cannot cut the land base down, because every colour has to be fixable. The result is a 28-card mana base that costs more than the entire rest of the list.
Matchups: What to Expect in cEDH
MTGMeta’s head-to-head record over 180 days gives the clearest picture, based on 111 matchups with five or more recorded games.
Against Kraum, Ludevic’s Opus + Tymna the Weaver (51%, 213-205 over 418 matches)
This is the most-played matchup in the archetype by a wide margin, and Sisay edges it. Blue Farm is faster to assemble and has better early interaction, but the Sisay shell has a larger top end and a much deeper finisher list — the tutor chain can fetch whatever answers the board state demands. The game usually comes down to who wins the first exchange of counterspells.
Against Kinnan, Bonder Prodigy (51%, 196-188 over 384 matches)
Nearly even, and the highest-stakes matchup on the list. Kinnan assembles infinite mana faster than almost anything in the format, so a Sisay player who lets Kinnan establish Basalt Monolith is already behind. The plan is to tutor out your win condition early and race, while holding Fierce Guardianship and Force of Will for the Kinnan activation itself.
Against Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh + Thrasios, Triton Hero (45%, 140-174 over 314 matches)
The one matchup where the table is clearly ahead. Rograkh’s discard-based disruption hits a deck that wants to hold a deep hand of combo pieces and tutors, and the haste creatures close games before the legendary density pays off. Expect to be behind on cards and ahead on board, and plan accordingly.
Against Rograkh, Son of Rohgahh + Silas Renn, Seeker Adept (54%, 135-115 over 250 matches)
Better against the two-player Rograkh pairing than the three-player one, because Silas Renn draws less on the turn you need to assemble. The discard is still the problem — but with a faster tutor chain you can put a win condition down before the disruption lands.
Against Thrasios, Triton Hero + Tymna the Weaver (55%, 94-77 over 171 matches)
Sisay’s best recorded matchup against the partner shells. Thrasios supplies exactly what the archetype wants — card advantage and a fast clock — but the shell has less interaction than Blue Farm and no early discard, so the Sisay tutor chain gets to run its full course.
How to Get Started
Building Sisay cEDH in paper costs roughly US$10,950 at current market pricing. The expensive cards are almost entirely lands and mana rocks: Gaea’s Cradle (US$1,649.66), Mox Diamond (US$1,119.70), Underground Sea (US$1,099.49), Volcanic Island (US$1,007.98) and Tundra (US$715.24). Outside the mana base, only three cards cross the US$200 mark — Mox Opal at US$221.60, Gilded Drake at US$214.34 and Chrome Mox at US$164.54. Sisay herself is US$2.60 and the entire non-land shell costs US$3,124 for 72 cards.
That price concentration is the entire argument for playing proxies. The deck’s cost is a land-price artefact, not a gameplay one — Underground Sea and Gaea’s Cradle are expensive because they are old, reserved-list, and in demand, not because they are hard to print.
For players who want the full cEDH experience without the five-figure price tag, printing the entire 100-card list costs about $80 at MakeProxyCard — Sisay, Agatha’s Soul Cauldron, Emiel the Blessed, Derevi and every staple in the 99 print at tournament quality with sharp text and accurate colours. At the 91-198 card tier that is US$0.80 per card, and the proxy version plays identically at your kitchen table, your local cEDH night, or any proxy-friendly event.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
- MTGMeta — cEDH Sisay, Weatherlight Captain archetype, play rates and matchups
- MTGMeta — cEDH metagame overview
- Learn cEDH — Sisay decklist primer and combo lines
- MTGTop8 — cEDH Sisay decklists and metagame share
- Scryfall — Sisay, Weatherlight Captain
- Scryfall — Agatha’s Soul Cauldron
- Scryfall — Enduring Vitality
- Scryfall — Emiel the Blessed
- Scryfall — Derevi, Empyrial Tactician
- Scryfall — Mount Doom
- Wizards of the Coast — Commander format
Related Reading
The five links above cover the three cEDH archetypes Sisay is measured against, the pricing guide that explains why a five-colour land base costs what it does, and the pillar page covering the proxy rules and tiers used in the cost table.
