
How to Order MTG Proxies: Minimum Order, Shipping, and the Tier Sweet Spot
How to order MTG proxies without overpaying comes down to two checkout thresholds that almost every guide skips: the US$39.99 minimum order and the US$4.99 shipping fee — and the fact that both are measured against the same US$39.99 line, so every order you are able to complete ships free. That single mechanic changes what the per-card rate table really means. A 29-card order is the smallest one that clears the minimum, and it costs US$40.60. A 100-card Commander deck costs US$80.00. But two 50-card orders cost US$120.00 for the same cards one 100-card order costs US$80.00 — 50% more for identical proxies. This guide is the arithmetic behind the checkout screen: how to size an order, when one big order beats two small ones, where the tier cliffs are, and why adding a single card can lower your total. Card artwork comes from Scryfall, and the deck lists referenced here are the ones EDHREC tracks for every week of play.
What This Article Covers
- The US$39.99 minimum order, and the smallest order that actually clears it
- Why shipping is free on every order you are allowed to complete
- The five tier cliffs where adding one card lowers your total
- Split versus combine: the arithmetic of one big order versus several
- Full Color versus Foil, and the flat US$0.20 gap at every tier
Quick Facts
The US$39.99 Minimum Order
Most people discover the minimum order by accident. You build a 12-card deck, add it to the cart, and the checkout refuses to go through. That is not a bug and it is not a shipping restriction — it is a print-run floor. Proxy cards are printed in press batches, and a batch carries a setup cost whether it holds twelve cards or six hundred. The floor exists so a print run is never run at a loss.
The practical consequence is that a small “just testing the waters” order is not available on its own. Here is the exact arithmetic, taken from the live tier table rather than a rounded-off example:
So at standard tier prices the real minimum order is 29 cards, not 12. If you want a starter set, the cheapest one that actually ships is a 29-card order at US$40.60. If you plan to test several small decks over time, order one 29-card batch and keep it as a shared starter pool rather than trying to buy four tiny orders that each get rejected.
There is one subtlety worth knowing, because it surprises people. The threshold is measured against your subtotal after any discount is applied. When a sitewide promotion is running, the discount reduces your subtotal first, and the US$39.99 floor is then measured against that reduced figure. A promotion therefore means you need more cards to clear the minimum, not fewer. Plan your order size against the post-discount number shown in your cart.
Shipping: The Threshold That Cancels Itself
Here is the part that makes ordering proxies unusually pleasant compared to buying almost anything else online. MakeProxyCard’s shipping is US$4.99 flat, and free once your subtotal reaches US$39.99 — and the minimum order is also US$39.99, measured on the same number.
That means the two thresholds land on the same line. Any order large enough to be accepted at checkout is also large enough to ship free. The US$4.99 figure is the rate that appears on a cart below the minimum — and a cart below the minimum cannot be completed anyway. In practice:
Shipping is a flat rate, not a per-card or per-weight charge. A 29-card order and a 612-card order both ship free, and both travel the same route: one rigid mailer, cardboard stiffeners between the stacks, and enough internal padding that the corners do not take a beating in transit. If you are outside the United States, the same flat rate applies — there is no international surcharge layered on top of the US$4.99, and nothing customs-shaped added at checkout.
This is why the per-card rate table is worth reading twice. The US$1.60 starting rate is a real number, but it is a rate, not a receipt. The receipt is whatever your tier says, and the tier is set by how many cards you put in the order.

- An order under US$39.99 shows US$4.99 shipping, and cannot be checked out.
- Every completed order ships with US$0.00 shipping.
Size Your Order to Land in the Right Tier
The quantity tiers are the whole pricing model. The rate falls as the order grows, and the drops are not evenly spaced — they are cliffs, and at each one the price per card steps down for every card in the order, not just the new ones.
The most common order — a 100-card Commander deck — lands at tier 91-198, which is US$0.80 per card and US$80.00 for the deck. A 360-card cube lands at tier 235-504 for US$216.00, or US$0.60 per card. Both are comfortably past the minimum order, so both ship free.
Where the Cliffs Are
The counterintuitive part is that a bigger order can cost less than a smaller one, because the per-card rate applies retroactively to the whole batch. Five cliffs matter in practice:
If your deck list sits two or three cards short of a cliff, the fix is almost never to trim the deck. It is to add the cards you were already deliberating — the alternate win condition, the second ramp, the card you own in paper but want to sleeve. You are not buying filler; you are buying the last few cards of the deck you wanted to play anyway, and the rate drops on every card in the order while you are at it.

- 18 to 19 cards. An 18-card order costs US$33.79 including shipping. Nineteen cards cost US$31.59. One extra card, US$2.20 cheaper.
- 36 to 37 cards. US$50.40 drops to US$44.40. You save US$6.00 by adding one card.
- 55 to 56 cards. US$66.00 drops to US$50.40 — the steepest drop in the first half of the table, US$15.60 for one card.
- 90 to 91 cards. US$81.00 drops to US$72.80, saving US$8.20 and putting a Commander deck into its cheapest sensible band.
- 198 to 199 cards. US$158.40 drops to US$139.30, saving US$19.10 across a two-deck order.
One Big Order or Several Small Ones
This is where ordering mistakes are most expensive, and the arithmetic is not subtle once you have the tier table in front of you.
Two separate 50-card orders cost US$120.00. One combined 100-card order costs US$80.00. The same hundred cards, in the same hands, at a US$40.00 difference — 50% more for splitting the order.
The pattern holds all the way up. Splitting a two-deck order into two 100-card orders costs US$160.00 against US$140.00 combined. A 100-card Commander deck plus a 60-card Modern list is US$134.00 as two orders and US$128.00 as one. The saving is always there, and it grows with the order size because each separate order recharges you the higher rate for its smaller quantity.
So the practical rule is simple: one checkout, as many cards as you can honestly fill it with. If you play Commander and Modern, order both decks together. If your playgroup wants in, collect the card counts first and submit one combined order. The only reason to split is if you genuinely need part of the order sooner — and since shipping is free on every completed order, splitting does not save you a shipping fee either. It only ever costs you rate.

Full Color Versus Foil: A Flat US$0.20 Gap
Foil has its own price ladder, and it is worth understanding exactly how it relates to Full Color. At every single tier, foil costs exactly US$0.20 more per card than Full Color:
A constant additive gap means the foil decision is arithmetic, not aesthetic guesswork. Foiling all 100 cards of a Commander deck costs US$100.00 against US$80.00 for Full Color — US$20.00 for a finish change across the whole deck.
Which raises the obvious follow-up: is it cheaper to split the order and foil only the cards you care about? Usually not. Splitting an 85-card Full Color order from a 15-card foil order costs US$108.49 across the two orders — more than the US$100.00 it costs to foil the entire hundred cards in one order. The split buys you a finish difference on fifteen cards and charges you a rate penalty on a hundred. If you want foil on a handful of cards, the cleanest play is to make the whole order foil, or to accept Full Color across the board and keep the money. The full tier table is on our pricing reference page.
The Bottom Line: What Your Order Actually Costs
Order size is the only lever that matters, and it is a bigger lever than most people expect. The minimum order of US$39.99 sets a floor of 29 cards at standard tier prices. Everything above that is a decision about how many cards to put in one checkout. One order beats two orders every time, the rate steps down at five specific cliffs, and every completed order ships free regardless of size.
Frequently Asked Questions
Sources
Every per-card rate quoted in this guide was checked against the live pricing table and checkout configuration on 28 October 2026, and each figure matches the published tier table exactly.
Related Reading
Start with the pillar guide above if proxy rules are still new to you, then use the tier math on this page to size your order.
- MTG Proxy Prices 2026 — the full quantity tier table behind the US$80 Commander deck figure, plus what proxied Commander, cube and staple packages cost.
- MTG Proxy Playtesting — how to test a deck for US$197 in paper before spending US$80 on proxies, and which cards are worth including in a starter order.
- MTG Proxy Decision Guide — a four-tier priority framework for deciding which cards in a deck are worth proxying and which are cheaper to buy outright.
- The Complete MTG Proxy Guide 2026 — the pillar hub covering legality, costs, quality, formats, storage and etiquette in one place.
